Newsletter
Subscribe
STOP THE TALENT BLEED
GROW YOUR NEXT LEAD CARPENTER & PROJECT MANAGER FROM WITHIN
Stop struggling with hiring. Learn practical strategies for Builders to develop Lead Carpenters & Project Managers from your existing team for loyalty & growth.

by Grant Fuellenbach

The Challenge of Finding & Keeping Talent
You're a Builder, not a full-time recruiter. Yet, finding and keeping top-notch Lead Carpenters and Project Managers feels like a constant battle, doesn't it? You lose good people, projects suffer, and your growth stalls. What if the answer wasn't always "out there" but right within your own crew? Investing in your team to develop leaders isn't just a "nice-to-do"—it's a hard-nosed business strategy that pays off in loyalty, lower costs, a stronger culture, and ultimately, a more scalable and profitable business.
This isn't about fancy theories; it's about practical steps you can take to build your leadership pipeline.
The Problem
Constant recruiting and turnover of key positions
The Solution
Developing leadership from within your existing team
The Outcome
More loyalty, stability, and profitable growth

Table of contents

Table of contents

⚡ TL;DR
WHY BOTHER?
Growing your own leaders means more loyalty, lower hiring costs, a stronger company culture, and better project outcomes.
KEY ROLES, CLEAR PATHS
Define what it takes to become a rockstar Lead Carpenter and a dialed-in Project Manager in your company.
THE HOW-TO
Combine smart, structured training (think OJT with purpose, key certs) with the power of mentorship and practical coaching.
LEADERSHIP IS KEY
If you, the owner, don't champion this, it won't happen. Period.
Why "Growing Your Own" Is A Game-Changer
BLUF: Pouring into your existing team to build your future Lead Carpenters and Project Managers isn't just feel-good stuff. It directly impacts your bottom line by boosting loyalty, slashing recruitment nightmares, protecting your hard-earned company culture, and ensuring vital know-how stays in-house.
Boosts Loyalty & Keeps Your Best
Employees who see a clear path for growth are far more likely to stick around
Protects Your Company Culture
Internal promotions mean leaders who already get "how we do things here"
Slashes Hiring Costs & Time
Recruiting externally is expensive and time-consuming
Keeps Know-How In-House
Invaluable company-specific knowledge gets passed on, not lost
The Two Critical Roles You Need To Nurture
These aren't just job titles; they're pivotal roles that can make or break your projects and your company's growth.
LEAD CARPENTER:
FROM SKILLED HANDS TO SITE LEADER
This is more than your best carpenter. A true Lead Carpenter runs their crew effectively, ensures quality work on site, foresees problems, and essentially acts as your trusted eyes and ears on the job, coordinating daily workflow and materials. They are a craftsperson and a frontline leader.
PROJECT MANAGER:
THE JOB ORCHESTRATOR
The PM is the hub. They plan, coordinate with clients and subs, manage the budget, maintain the schedule, and solve problems to keep projects moving smoothly and profitably from start to finish. Their ability to manage complexity is key to your scalability.
📐 QUICK START: MAP YOUR BASIC CAREER LADDER
  • Action: Grab a piece of paper. For your company, jot down 3-5 core skills or milestones someone needs to hit to move from their current role to Lead Carpenter.
  • Action: Now, do the same for a Lead Carpenter to become a Project Manager. What new skills in planning, client communication, or financial tracking are essential?
  • Question: What's one thing you could teach an aspiring crew member this month to start them on the path to Lead Carpenter?
Core Strategies:
Your Internal Talent Pipeline Blueprint
You don't need a massive HR department. You need a practical approach.
STRUCTURED SKILL DEVELOPMENT
  • On-the-Job Training (OJT) WITH PURPOSE: Don't just leave it to chance.
  • Pair less experienced team members with seasoned pros on specific tasks.
  • Define clear learning objectives for each project they’re on.
  • Targeted Formal Training: Think practical and applicable.
  • Encourage relevant certifications: OSHA for safety, NARI Certified Lead Carpenter (CLC) for your top hands, or even modules from a PMP program for aspiring PMs if you're growing.
  • Consider local community college courses or focused online workshops for specific skills (e.g., blueprint reading, basic estimating).
  • Simple Competency Checklists:
  • For each role (Lead Carpenter, PM), list the key skills, knowledge, and behaviors needed. (e.g., "Reads blueprints accurately," "Leads a morning huddle effectively," "Updates project budget weekly").
  • Use this as a guide for development discussions and performance reviews.
MENTORSHIP: THE ACCELERATOR FOR GROWTH
BLUF: Pairing your seasoned veterans with your rising stars is one of the fastest ways to transfer critical knowledge, build confidence, and reinforce your company culture.
  • It’s More Than Coffee: Good mentorship is structured.
  • Focus: Help mentees build specific skills (technical and soft), navigate company culture, and get honest career guidance.
  • Pairing: Match based on the mentee’s goals and some personality fit. Crucially, give your mentors some basic guidance on how to be a good mentor.
  • Benefits are Huge: Think faster skill development, better problem-solving, and a real sense of connection to the company.
COACHING: FINE-TUNING FOR PEAK PERFORMANCE
  • Skill-Specific Focus: Coaching is about helping individuals sharpen specific skills or overcome particular challenges.
  • Example for Lead Carpenter: Improving crew motivation or job site organization.
  • Example for PM: Enhancing client negotiation skills or financial reporting accuracy.
  • Keep it Simple: You don’t need to be a certified coach. Use a basic framework.
  • GROW Model Example: Goal (What do they want to achieve?), Reality (Where are they now?), Options (What could they do?), Will (What will they do, and by when?).
📐 QUICK START: LAUNCH A PILOT MENTOR PAIRING
  • Action: Identify one promising team member who's eager to learn and one experienced, respected leader who's good at explaining things.
  • Action: Ask them to meet twice in the next month. Give them ONE specific skill or area for the mentee to focus on developing with the mentor's guidance.
  • Follow-up: Get feedback from both. What worked? What could be better?
Common Hurdles
(And How To Jump Them)
"WE DON'T HAVE THE TIME OR BUDGET!"
The Fix: The cost of high turnover, project mistakes due to untrained leaders, and constantly recruiting is far higher. Start small and focused. Even one good mentor pairing or one targeted training session is a start.
RESISTANCE FROM THE "OLD GUARD"
The Fix: Clearly communicate the "What's In It For Me?" for everyone. For existing leaders, it means stronger teams and less firefighting. For the company, it's stability and growth. Get visible buy-in from the very top.
INCONSISTENT EFFORTS & QUALITY
The Fix: Write down your basic expectations for mentors or OJT. Provide simple guidelines. Check in regularly. Consistency beats complexity.
The Bottom Line
Invest in your team
Develop raw talent intentionally
Build loyalty
Create clear growth paths
Scale profitably
Grow a business that doesn't solely rely on you
Stop thinking of talent development as a cost center or something only big companies do. For Builders looking to scale profitably and build a business that doesn't solely rely on them, growing your own Lead Carpenters and Project Managers is non-negotiable. It builds loyalty, embeds your culture, saves you money in the long run, and creates a stronger, more capable team ready to tackle bigger and better projects.
You have the raw talent. It's time to intentionally shape it.
Since 2021, GO First® has helped 312+ builders leverage AI and automation to create predictable sales pipelines and escape the feast-or-famine cycle.
Subscribe to the 'Beyond the Bid' newsletter for weekly tips on AI-driven sales strategies for builders:
Free Resources
10-Step Sales Process
Discover how the top 5% of building company owners get booked 6-12 months in advance
Remodeling Process PlaybookMaster client communication, streamline sales, build trust, win better projects.
The Dream 100
Clarity to make smart, valuable decisions that go far beyond the basic blueprint.
300pt. QA Checklist
The Ultimate Guide to Consistent Quality.
Solving the Subcontractor Challenge
Practical solutions to effective strategies for vetting, and securing quality subcontractors
The Profitable Change Order Kit
A professional template and a 4-step process to protect your profit and maintain client trust.
109 SOPs Every Team Needs
Free resource of example standard procedures
Visit the Blog
Process best practices and quick tips
DIG DEEPER
How to use Apollo.io
Online training for Apollo beginners
How to use HubSpot
Online training for HubSpot beginners
How to use Monday
Online training for Monday beginners
Frequently Asked Questions
Get answers to the questions builders and remodelers have about growing business.
Join Our Team
Make an impact on Team GO First
GO Firsts' Mission
About our mission and why it matters
Our Toolbox
Check out our favorite gear and software
WORK WITH US
GO Firsts' MAP™
Our signature program to systemize small teams
The FrameWork™
Stop chasing unpredictable results and scale from reactive to proactive sales.
Company Training
Private Virtual or On-Site Instructions by Grant at GO First
GO First Consulting & Design. All Rights Reserved (c) 2025. Privacy Policy